Highlander The Series - Season 1 Sword of the Dragon Review

BeLikeWater

Active Member
RPF PREMIUM MEMBER
Hi everyone,

I'm not going to bore you with the trials and tribulations of being a Highlander fan. If you know the franchise, you know the official merchandise was always **** (like the sequels!), with the exception of the excellent video and dvd collections.

For all matters regarding swords, it took the initiative of fans to set things right. And though the series may be dead and gone, the dreams of a Highlander fan are entirely possible now.

Daryl Kyle. If this dude keeps up his quality and customer service, his name is going to be legend in the prop world. He has the blessing of Sal D'Aquila (the original propmaker for the series and creator of the Season 1 Sword of the Dragon), and after working with him, I see why.

When Daryl and Sal made it possible for me to obtain an original Season 1 katana (taken from the mold used in the series), there was no question I was going to have one. It was just a matter of when, how much, and what blade.

Daryl reminded/warned me many times that the Season 1 was not a Musashi katana. The Musashi Katana is Sal's refined version of the Season 1. They are literally night and day. I have a Musashi built by Sal with a Paul Chen Bushido blade, and it's amazing. I can't compare the swords. The Season 1 handle is unrefined, imperfect, and raw. But that's it's appeal!

Now, back to the Season 1...

Daryl was straight with me. He told me he could make me a Season 1 with an aluminum blade, a stainless blade (the marto tachi used in the original series), OR...I could go all-out and get a real blade made. He would handle all the back-and-forth with the blademakers. All I'd have to do is give the OK every step of the way.

And that's exactly how it went.

Whenever I'd ask, Daryl would consistenly update me on the progress of the katana. He'd show me photos of the handle, and ask how I wanted it painted. We're talking down to the EXACT EPISODE here, people. If you wanted a Season 1 katana the way it looked in Episode (insert random episode here), Daryl could do it. If a clear screenshot was available, Daryl could make it happen. And in the end, you OK it. He does nothing without your greenlight.

I chose to have my handle look similar to the first episode, The Gathering. In that episode, the handle is a more cream/yellow, and there's barely any shading/detail. My additional instructions to Daryl were, "Make it look like it's been around for 400 years."

When the blades came in, Daryl took pictures and sent them to me before they were mounted. He assured me that if I saw something wrong, they'd go right back to the bladesmith. Luckily, they came out fine.

This sword is real. To quote Daryl, this is what you'd want at your side during a zombie invasion.

When I finally received it, there were no words. I spent an hour talking to Daryl, holding the sword in my hand the entire time. The blade is a beast. However, the balance was so great, my arm never felt fatigued.

Here's some specs on the blade:

Nagasa length - 76 cm (from mune machi)
Sori Curvature - 3cm
Tang - 20 - 25 cm - Straight
1095 folded steel - laminated over 1060 for flexibility
Short Kissaki
Authentic Hamon - Gunome Style Sawtooth
Brass Habaki with rounded top
Saya - Dark Brown lacquered
Sageo - Dark Brown

I wanted to wait to review this because I wanted to be able to review it objectively. After over 8 months of having this katana, I'm still in awe of it. I feel like it's equal parts an accomplishment on my part as it is Daryl's. I helped to build the Season 1 katana of my dreams, and Daryl made it possible.

Now here's the best part. Daryl's swords come with what's essentially a lifetime warranty. If there's an issue, or something you don't like down the road, Daryl is open to working with you on it. It's not just a "one and done" thing with him. He genuinely wants you to be happy.

I also had a Season 1 made for a buddy of mine. His is based on the episode Mountain Men. His review will be forthcoming.

So that's it! Visit Welcome to Point Gallery if you're interested in having one yourself. If you're a big Highlander fan, you won't regret it.
 

Attachments

  • DSC02028.JPG
    DSC02028.JPG
    2.6 MB · Views: 2,937
  • DSC02029.JPG
    DSC02029.JPG
    2.4 MB · Views: 1,755
  • DSC02030.JPG
    DSC02030.JPG
    2.6 MB · Views: 2,048
  • DSC02032.JPG
    DSC02032.JPG
    2.2 MB · Views: 1,109
Last edited:
That is just fabulous. Always loved that particular sword, I'm glad to see they're still making them!
 
Wow! That's also my favorite version of the Series katana. I think you just helped me add this to my "must have" list. :D
 
Beautiful Kat but thats to be expected from Darryl.

Love your choice of the color of the handle, I might go that way myself
 
I've seen quoted on another person's online review of their True Season 1 sword that it has 25 differences from the Musashi Season 1 sword. Can you give us an idea of what these 25 differences are?

When I hear that the Musashi is a "refined" version of the True Season 1, I guess I'm just thinking that some of the lines and shapes were cleaned up a bit to endure closer inspection than was necessary with the True Season 1 sword, but 25 differences doesn't just sound like general refinement—it sounds like Sal may have made a point to make more obvious changes when creating the Musashi Season 1 in an effort to perhaps preserve the rarity of the True Season 1 sword, which was his right and which I understand.

It would be great if someone actually did a photo comparison of the True Season 1 and the Musashi Season 1 side by side so that folks like myself can get an idea of the differences in the two.

I've always wanted a Season 1 sword, having sold off my Marto many moons ago. When I found Sal's site, I began justifying in my mind why spending $1K plus on a functional sword was necessary. Then, almost when I'd gotten to the point of pulling the trigger on a Musashi, I read somewhere that the Musashi katana he sold was not the True Season 1, but his resculpt of the Season 1, and that a replica of his original sculpt True Season 1 could be had, but for a much higher price not mentioned on the site (at the time).

So then it was back to justifying in my mind why I need a $3K sword as opposed to a $1K sword. Other than the obvious fact that the True Season 1 handle comes from the actual original TV mold, I would need more information to bridge that $2K gap, and I'm probably not the only one that would love to hear more details on the differences between the original True Season 1 and Sal's later Musashi resculpt.

On a side note, it's interesting that you mention the different handles between episodes. I remember one episode in which the sword looked almost transparent with a slight purplish hue to the dragon head area... Me personally, I always liked the way it looked in the Gathering as well, when it was first pulled from under the bed.
 
I've seen quoted on another person's online review of their True Season 1 sword that it has 25 differences from the Musashi Season 1 sword. Can you give us an idea of what these 25 differences are?

When I hear that the Musashi is a "refined" version of the True Season 1, I guess I'm just thinking that some of the lines and shapes were cleaned up a bit to endure closer inspection than was necessary with the True Season 1 sword, but 25 differences doesn't just sound like general refinement—it sounds like Sal may have made a point to make more obvious changes when creating the Musashi Season 1 in an effort to perhaps preserve the rarity of the True Season 1 sword, which was his right and which I understand.

It would be great if someone actually did a photo comparison of the True Season 1 and the Musashi Season 1 side by side so that folks like myself can get an idea of the differences in the two.

I've always wanted a Season 1 sword, having sold off my Marto many moons ago. When I found Sal's site, I began justifying in my mind why spending $1K plus on a functional sword was necessary. Then, almost when I'd gotten to the point of pulling the trigger on a Musashi, I read somewhere that the Musashi katana he sold was not the True Season 1, but his resculpt of the Season 1, and that a replica of his original sculpt True Season 1 could be had, but for a much higher price not mentioned on the site (at the time).

So then it was back to justifying in my mind why I need a $3K sword as opposed to a $1K sword. Other than the obvious fact that the True Season 1 handle comes from the actual original TV mold, I would need more information to bridge that $2K gap, and I'm probably not the only one that would love to hear more details on the differences between the original True Season 1 and Sal's later Musashi resculpt.

On a side note, it's interesting that you mention the different handles between episodes. I remember one episode in which the sword looked almost transparent with a slight purplish hue to the dragon head area... Me personally, I always liked the way it looked in the Gathering as well, when it was first pulled from under the bed.

Thanks everyone for the kind words.

Great questions, SpyHunter2k. Attached photos of the Musashi for you.

Let me run down my history with Sal and the Musashi...

I actually purchased an early/original Musashi with a Kris Cutlery blade when they were first available in early 2000/2001. I ended up selling it a month later. First of all, I wasn't into art, craftsmanship, or swords at the time. I must have been around 18. I only cared about having a Season 1 proper, and it was the closest thing I could get. When I received the Musashi, it wasn't a Season 1 at all. I was pretty deflated.

In addition, the original Kris Cutlery blades were beefy and short (in comparison to the tachi blades used on the series). The katana was incredibly blade-heavy, and that just made it even more inelegant to me. I really didn't like it. Just wasn't what I envisioned. Not Sal's fault at all. Just wasn't my thing at the time.

Cut to 7 years later, and Sal is still making these swords, and everyone who has one is raving about them. So I get curious again. I find out that Sal is being more flexible with the blades. He's opened up to using Chen Bushido blades, Practical Plus, and, at one time, even Shinto!

I got to the point where I just wanted to have a sword made by the man who did the series, even if it wasn't entirely accurate. So I went ahead and pulled the trigger a second time.

I purchased my Musashi from him sometime in 2011 or 2012. I was able to obtain one with a Bushido Blade. This is the sword pictured in the photos.

I was floored by the difference. Maybe it was just me being more mature, or maybe it was Sal getting even better at his art, but the Musashi I have now is just incredible. I was stunned when I received it, and am still in awe of it. It's light, beautiful, and something completely different from the original Kris Cutlery version. In addition, and I may be crazy, but even the texture of the handle felt different. I remembered the original Kris Cutlery version being really "chalky" and rough. This new version was much smoother.

The differences between the Season 1 and the Musashi are pretty big to a discerning eye (i.e. a hardcore fan of the show). The dragon head is shaped differently, I think the neck is slightly longer (or maybe the dragon head is just bigger), and the images on the handle are flipped. I'm sure Daryl's going to chime in on this thread sooner or later, so he could give you more specifics.

If someone asked me which is better, they wouldn't get an answer they'd like. The Musashi is completely different from the Season 1. They may look similar, but in person, just take my word for it. I love both these katanas equally, and for different reasons. Believe me, I never thought I'd be saying that.

So if you want a Highlander sword from the first season, you gotta go with getting a Season 1 over the Musashi. It's gonna be dirtier, aged, and rough around the edges. But that's the point. You'll be satisfied if that's what you want.

If you want something that's a piece of art, go with the Musashi.

Most important, the blades make a big difference too. If Daryl had told me that I could only have a Chen blade on the Season 1, I would have said no way. The blade length is a big deal with the Season 1 if you want it to be an accurate representation of the series.

Daryl is really flexible in this regard, so you shouldn't have any problems.
 
Last edited:
THANKS! A couple of the photos were from almost the exact same angle so I was able to rotate/size them and put together these comparison shots.

First, the right side, Musashi Season 1 on top, True Season 1 on bottom:

rtsidecomparison.png



Looking at this side, the scenes on the handle seem to have slightly better depth/relief on the TS1 than the MS1, like the person's hand coming from their sleeve and going into the pot just above the animal panel.

I can see some changes, like the the swirled area at the top rear of the dragon head, the rearmost tooth of the dragon, the gilled area underneath the dragon's eyes...

It looks like the only reversed panel between the two is the animal panel on the bottom.

Here's a comparison of the dragon's head, Musashi Season 1 on top, True Season 1 on bottom:

headcomparison.png


From this shot, the deeper detail on the dragon's head is more obvious. That said, you can actually see more detail on the side panel behind the dragon's head on the Musashi, but I think that's just because of the heavier antiquing on the Musashi in this particular area.

Again, thanks for posting close-up photos of both. I definitely think I'd prefer the True Season 1 over the Musashi Season 1, but since the TS1s are roughly triple the price, $3K+, of the $1K+ Musashis, it's a tough decision...
 
BEAUTIFUL SWORDS...would love to see what Adrian Paul thought of them if someone ever meet him at a convention and showed him one.
 
BEAUTIFUL SWORDS...would love to see what Adrian Paul thought of them if someone ever meet him at a convention and showed him one.

I was this close to showing him one at one point, but unfortunately we were in a public place. May get an opportunity in the summer!
 
Again, thanks for posting close-up photos of both. I definitely think I'd prefer the True Season 1 over the Musashi Season 1, but since the TS1s are roughly triple the price, $3K+, of the $1K+ Musashis, it's a tough decision...

Sure thing, Spyhunter2k. Glad I was able to help.

Regarding the price, yeah it's a bit expensive, no doubt. But when considering the history of official Highlander merchandise, and how overpriced everything has been regarding the series/films (Albion used to sell the H1 Masamune for $3,500), I feel like Daryl was the most fair in terms of price, the rarity of the prop, the custom work involved, and the deadline.
 
Thanks for the kind words guys, I feel each sword should be exactly what you want... Not a bunch of swords exactly the same... Also there are over 25 differences from the season 1 to the musashi and alot are known but not all and that's for a specific reason.,.. Before I took over point gallery someone tries to pass off a modified musashi as a season one and because I knew all the differences I was able to call BS.. But they are all very small and some you just won't know till you have them each in hand :)
 
These swords are the definition of exquisite! I can't even imagine the quality being better than these. Congrats to those that own these works of art!

I have the Marto sword from the late 90's and the Connor Signature edition but they are toy swords compared to these.
 
It looks great "Belikewater" congrats!!! And excellent comparison. I couldn't have said it better myself. Daryl is a master and great to deal with. Here's mine I hope you don't mind if I post it here:

Highlander:The Series Season 1&2 Duncan MacLeod Katana Sword - YouTube

I asked Daryl to make it white with light washes to make the details pop a bit, like The Ramirez/Connor Katana in Highlander 1.

Those are fantastic, Iceman1592. Really great stuff. I remember looking at some of these photos on the Highlander Community forum and being really impressed.

What blade do you have on the Mentor H1?
 
Back
Top