Troublesome TIE fighter greebly ID

mbraz

New Member
Hello RPF! I’m new here and I’ll introduce myself as a guy prepping to work on a studio scale TIE fighter.

Trying not to be too needy with part ID requests. I'll start out by thanking all the good folks on this forum who have shared photos, IDs, data, and general musings on TIEs over the years.

I thought this particular case would be generally interesting and worth asking the forum because I think more experienced folks than I have even struggled with it, too. Without naming any in particular, two really nice studio scale TIE Fighters that I have images of don’t seem to have gotten this part right (or they appear to have at ID'd the part differently).

The part in question is a U-shaped greeb on the beveled part of the central 'plinth' of the wing star hub (the bevel that orients in the vertical direction, usually down), sitting on top of a mast-type piece I believe is from the Airfix HMS Belfast and next to the Yardley vent:

U-part.png


I’ve highlighted this in green in the image above in panel A; unlabeled panel B for clarity. C and D are two castings of pyro models from the Propstore auction site. The images suggest there were bubbles in the mold which might add to the confusion/uncertainty about this part. C and D show something that appears to be descending between the masts of the Belfast part. A and B don't appear to show it. But C and D show more clusters of bubbles, suggesting to me that descending bit is also a cluster of bubble infills.

My current guess is that the U-shaped part is a towing hard-point seen often in British or American armoured vehicles (possibly with fitting nubs clipped off). I have guesses on two kits (one more “worrying” than the other $$$$$!).

Thanks in advance for any hints, clues, or feedback on my guess.
 
Not a TIE Fighter guy, but the model that immediately jumps to mind on seeing that shape is the Aurora 1/48 Munitions Carrier.
 
I don't know if my build falls into the "got it wrong" camp but I used a part from the 1/72 Hasegawa Sherman.

View attachment 1872180
Thanks! To be fair, I only wrote "don't seem to have gotten it right" (a lot of room for me to be the one getting it wrong!). I couldn't quite make out the part used in your TIE (which is a stunning piece of work, I should add!). I can see the resemblance with this part, but the hemispherical component doesn't seem to match with the pictures of the ILM model.

My thought was potentially one of these, but now also having doubts. One from the Tamiya 1:35 British Armoured Car Saladin MK-1 Kit No. MT-108, the other is from the Tamiya 1:35 M551 Sheridan:

Screenshot 2024-10-15 at 20.02.38.png
Screenshot 2024-10-15 at 20.04.02.png


However, these both seem to be a bit too wide in the part capping the U. Your part is a better fit on that count, but I still can't get over the hemispherical thing.
 
First, thank you.
Second, no offense taken. I just wasn't sure if mine fit in the correct or wrong camp. Trust me, there's plenty I got wrong on my build.
 
First, thank you.
Second, no offense taken. I just wasn't sure if mine fit in the correct or wrong camp. Trust me, there's plenty I got wrong on my build.
Yeah...I see them now swgeek; I'll gladly take it out of your hands/sight today (I'll pay for shipping):lol::lol::lol::p:p:p
 
Back
Top