I'm 3 episodes in and it's fine so far. It's not going to be the games and I don't want it to be. If I wanted the games, I'll go play the games. I want something in the world, which this definitely is. The casting isn't perfect. Lucy is good. At least they didn't turn her into a girl boss that kicked everyone's ass. The Ghoul is decent, although I wish they had spent some more time up front showing his background so that we understood why he is the way he is. Maximus is... okay, I guess. I'm trying to understand it from the perspective of someone who grew up in the Brotherhood and knows little else, but so far, he hasn't grabbed me.
They're doing a ton of memberberries, which is fine to a certain degree, but they have to stand on their own two feet so we'll see how the end of the show goes. So far, I'm on board, which is a lot more than I was expecting.