Ronson Colonial Lighter (1936)
I've been trying to find a decent quality one of these for awhile as they're somewhat rare compared to many other common Ronson models, probably because they were only briefly made in the 1930s instead of updated versions in the 1940s like many others. Another one I'm looking for called the "Regal" has two other versions named that, but one is a pocket lighter and the other looks NOTHING like the 1936 version so it's also rare for the same basic reason.
There's been one on eBay for months now that looks like it's in good shape (the top part looks a bit iffy as it's kind of not shiny at all like there's soap on it or something hiding something), but the guy wants $159 (later $149) opening bid and after 4+ months, he's had zero bids. He added "Or Best Offer" but the book price is $60-80 in EXCELLENT condition, not $149 and despite offering $20 more than that ($100), it AUTO-REJECTED the offer. He can keep it until the end of time for all I care. I'm not paying twice the value just because he wants it. I want to win the lottery too, but tough....
I've passed on two other lighters I'm looking for (
Superba, which disappeared and may or may not have sold and a
Duchess, which is less rare and in sterling silver, but uglier than the brass version and has someone's flipping initials on it, which being in sterling, should be removable, but it's on a cylinder surface, so it's a much harder PITA to remove evenly than a flat pocket lighter monogram which you can just scrape off with a carbon steel file and then sand/polish like I did with the Bogart "Dark Passage" Adonis lighter in Sterling Silver.) Maybe the Duchess is worth that price being in Sterling (book price is based on 'ordinary' finishes), but the initials rub me the wrong way and the brass one in the book is so much cooler looking. The silver version just looks like a mirror cylinder. The Superba was massively overpriced at over double and that's with the chrome off the top flat part of the lighter as well (wouldn't call that "excellent" condition anymore so even worse asking MINT prices for below excellent).
Anyway, this one came up for auction and I ended up getting it for $60 ($70 with shipping and tax), well within its price range, if not higher since it's not exactly perfect looking. I tried to clean it up more, but based on the top part where some coating on the lighter started coming off the button and then looks shiny/perfect underneath and that Flitz did almost nothing for the rest of the body, I came to the conclusion all the "marks" on it are actually on a "clear coat" Ronson used on many lighters to protect the finish from tarnish. You can either put up with the inevitable imperfections that get on it like these marks (which look far worse in the photo than real life) or you can clean it off with an abrasive like paint remover and leave the silver plating exposed (which can then in turn tarnish and the plating can come off easier). Now I'm starting to wonder about some of the other examples I saw that looked like the plating was off, when in fact, the slight "rose colored" look it has from certain angles IS the clear coat here, not the "white metal" underneath that I thought it was. So who knows....
In any case, the lighter already sparked great. It just needed some fuel.....