Thanks Gene,
I think you area bout 99.9% correct. However I believe it is all about how informed a buyer is about a particular prop.
I knew that the best fan sculpted HeadPieces sell for $300-$450 (Magnoli, Redfour, Acme Magico). Through my investigation I was highly certain that this HP has lineage to a screen used HP (Imans House version). So knowing that and only paying $450, I felt that in the worst case scenario I was buying a prop that had value at the price I was paying.
Let's use another prop as an example;
If you came across a seller that has selling a real Sterling with all the correct attachments that was claiming to be production used (maybe used as a back-up) and came with a COA from a person that worked on the production and was selling it for $500 (the same price as an MR blaster), would you buy it? Would you say "no thanks"?
The worst thing you would have is a really nice prop that came from the hands of a person who worked on the film. Not bad.
The only person who would hate this is a collector that ONLY collects true production used props. Right?
I don't feel taken advantage of at all. I think I got a great deal seeing that I paid the lowest price ever for one of these. Also I never believed 100% what the seller was shoveling.
Anyone buying a supposed production made or screen used prop for pennies on the dollar and believes whole-hearted that they are getting the real deal is living in dreamland. BUYER BEWARE!!!
Brad