So, what's QMX got up their sleeve?

I've been keeping my typing fingers still on this one, but here are my two pennies:

- Cabridges, I agree with almost every comment you've made so far.

- I applaud QMX for giving us more options and I kinda think it's unfair to throw that back in their faces. As a company, I don't see what else they can do. They tried to offer a product, failed miserably due to both their actions (hasty promises) and (as far as we know) due to a crappy manufacturer. Now they're finally trying to rectify it. I remember in the very beginning when everyone was screaming for a full Metal Mal and now it seems to be on the way. For those that want a refund- go get it, you've always had that option. They're not asking for more money now for the Metal one 'cause they're dropped the pre-order policy.

- I think the stunt version looks pretty decent, especially compared to other expensive resin pistols like the Hellboy Samaritan by Sideshow (which I have and dearly love, despite its plasticyness). I am familiar with the technique they seem to be using. You blend real metal powder into the resin and you "dust" the molds with it as well so that you get a top layer that is almost pure metal. From what I've read, you can get a real metal shine by buffing it. The real gun never has a mirror-finish anyway and it certainly looks as good as (or better than) some of MR's finishes (like the weathering on the Boba rifle). However, I would definitely have liked to have at least the wooden grips on the stunt. Wood grips are 90% of the feel in my opinion. But an American made, hand finished prop for $150 bucks? That's still a gorram deal in our hobby. That's almost what we usually pay around these parts for unfinished resin castings!

- The metal prototype pics definitely look like Siderios work, albeit modified. There are too many similarities to be a coincidence. We know Siderio did a decent job on the Firefly version, so the final gun will probably turn out pretty good and there's a pretty good chance it'll actually see the light of day. QMX has so far recognized the talents of other people 'round here, like Ben, so it's only natural they'd contact Sid too. I do hope that they get the parts plated though. They will have to make the metal version pretty special to convince those people that already have Sids metal Firefly version that they need one more.
 
My only problem with them using a modified SidKit pistol is that his wasn't 100% accurate either, a recast of a cast...They would have been better off getting him to re-do his parts from the actual casting of the Serenity pistol.

Personally I don't like the look of the stunt pistol so far, it looks like painted resin in the pics, though perhaps the finished product will look better.
 
My only problem with them using a modified SidKit pistol is that his wasn't 100% accurate either, a recast of a cast...They would have been better off getting him to re-do his parts from the actual casting of the Serenity pistol.

Personally I don't like the look of the stunt pistol so far, it looks like painted resin in the pics, though perhaps the finished product will look better.

Maybe they're only using Sids model for the prototype. Surely they'll be casting their own parts from a screen used pistol for the finished product won't they?
I'm not too keen on the finish of the stunt pistol either, especially the black spray painted look around the hammer. I personally prefer the prototype paint job. It's also a shame they made the guard too thick and molded the trigger and guard in one piece. When I was lucky enough to get the prototype that QMx made it was really the only thing that let it down, and I was hoping they would change it later on.

Despite that, I think it's still a bargain for $150. I would have bought one, if they hadn't announced it the day before the imitation firearms ban starts in the UK.:cry
 
But he pistol is supposedly taken from casts of an original. I wonder how thick the trigger guard is on the screen used? I was just watching Serenity and I think I actually noticed the trigger guard being kinda thick in one shot. Can't remember where though... but I think it was once of the times right after Mal pulls i from the holster and brings it up near his face.

Still... even with the firearms ban... the Mal pistol doesn't exactly look like a real firearm. If I were in the UK, I'd certainly risk loosing $150 to test the waters.


I personally prefer the prototype paint job. It's also a shame they made the guard too thick and molded the trigger and guard in one piece. When I was lucky enough to get the prototype that QMx made it was really the only thing that let it down, and I was hoping they would change it later on.

Despite that, I think it's still a bargain for $150. I would have bought one, if they hadn't announced it the day before the imitation firearms ban starts in the UK.:cry
 
Yeah, I've got the same problem being in the Uk. Waited so long for this, that now I can't get one! :thumbsdown
Im really not a big fan of just risking it being confiscated/destroyed personally. Throwing money away is a bit of a bad thing according to the better half..who knew!
 
Last edited:
Just to chime in with a detail - I had the chance to handle the screen-used stunt pistol, and the trigger guard is definately a little thicker than what you'd expect on the hero version.
 
Thanks for that Ben! Good to know. :thumbsup Was the lower trigger attached to the trigger guard?

I dunno... I'm kinda likin' the chunky look of it. It'd be kinda boring if it were just like the two Firefly versions I already have except for the magazine.

Just to chime in with a detail - I had the chance to handle the screen-used stunt pistol, and the trigger guard is definately a little thicker than what you'd expect on the hero version.
 
Is that the only repercussion of trying to import a replica? I thought you'd face criminal charges.

Yep, without a relevant defence as yet. The airsofters have their defence, collectors do not yet.

Anyone feel like being the 'test case'?
 
The biggest issue with using the Sidkit for new metal Mal gun is the price. I highly doubt Sid is retooling his whole gun to be an accurate copy of the screen used Serenity gun.
 
Yep, without a relevant defence as yet. The airsofters have their defence, collectors do not yet.

Anyone feel like being the 'test case'?

I bet they still charge the duty though :lol

Keep an eye on Forbidden Planet. They don't seem to have been deterred from listing weapon replicas.
 
Well, the parts breakdown pics of the prototype show a few significant changes in the magazine and trigger assembly.

If I had to guess I'd say QMX will have to keep the price under $500 if they expect to sell well. (I've a feeling most fans of the Verse would rather be buying multiple box sets to give away than spend hundreds on replicas.) If they do them up real nice with plating and wood grips, they'll probably end up real nice. I'll probably end up getting both if I have the money.

I gotta say... I'm feeling kinda upbeat. I just had a horrible, horrible, few days last week at work that kept me down all weekend. Watched Serenity today, working on my Jubal Early pistols, machining of my Vera parts should start any day and now the official Mal pistol is finally (almost) on the way.


The biggest issue with using the Sidkit for new metal Mal gun is the price. I highly doubt Sid is retooling his whole gun to be an accurate copy of the screen used Serenity gun.
 
Keep an eye on Forbidden Planet. They don't seem to have been deterred from listing weapon replicas.

They're no longer taking orders for this according to the item description:
Unfortunately due to the new UK law prohibiting the sale and distribution of replica firearms next month, the Serenity - Captain Mal Reynolds Sidearm Replica shipment has been cancelled.

I noticed that Play.com have also removed the item from sale.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
They're no longer taking orders for this according to the item description:


I noticed that Play.com have also removed the item from sale.

Play are based in Jersey and could in theory still supply to Channel Island customers as UK law doesn't apply to us, but I can't imagine they'd sell enough on such a limited market to make it worthwhile. :(

QMx are too late.
 
Okay so I'm lazy and don't want to read everything. What's the difference between this new "resin" version and the new "metal" version? Is it just the resin screws and grips?
 
Okay so I'm lazy and don't want to read everything. What's the difference between this new "resin" version and the new "metal" version? Is it just the resin screws and grips?

Actually it's the same as before - the first version advertised was also a resin version -- but it won't have the metal screws, the wood grip, or the display materials.
 
If I recall correctly, the first advertised version was resin, but was to be plated in copper and bronze. That way, although it would be light (and cheap) like resin, it would "feel" metallic. The new model does not have that feature - I know it has cold-cast metal, but no way does cold-cast metal feel the same is actual plating.
 
Okay so I'm lazy and don't want to read everything. What's the difference between this new "resin" version and the new "metal" version? Is it just the resin screws and grips?

The original was to be static resin, plated with real metal, and with metal screws and wood grips.

The new "stunt" is entirely static resin, including the grips and (I think) some screws, and it will not be plated.

The new "hero" is apparently all metal, potentially plated (it hasn't been said yet how it will be finished) with a working trigger and hammer, and with wood grips.

I think that's about it.
 
Actually it's the same as before - the first version advertised was also a resin version -- but it won't have the metal screws, the wood grip, or the display materials.

Please! It's a totally different beast...

It can't be the same as before when it is entirely different! This is the classic definition of an oxymoron... You say it's the same then go on to list no less then three differences yourself, and your difference list isn't nearly complete... It's simply not the same it's different, anything less is gorram junk, and this new version is less in every way...

The only common or same thing between the first advertised version and this version is that it is primarily cast in resin, other then that the differences are many and distinctly different...

The cold cast resin will have weight, and a cool feel but it will still feel and look like plastic and will require a faux (painted) finish to make it looked decent...
 
Back
Top